AG1 vs Competitors: Is the $100/Month Worth It?

AG1 (formerly Athletic Greens) is the most marketed supplement on the internet. Every podcast, every YouTube channel, every health influencer seems to have an AG1 sponsorship. The product claims to replace your multivitamin, greens powder, probiotic, and adaptogen stack with a single scoop. The price: $79–$99 per month depending on your subscription plan.

That is a lot of money for a powder. The question is not whether AG1 is a good product — it is whether it is $100/month better than the alternatives. We compared AG1 head-to-head with four competitors across ingredients, third-party testing, taste, and overall value.

What AG1 Actually Is

AG1 is a powdered blend of 75 vitamins, minerals, whole-food-sourced ingredients, probiotics, adaptogens, and digestive enzymes. You mix one scoop with water and drink it daily. The ingredient list is long and covers a genuinely wide range of nutritional bases.

Key ingredients include: Spirulina, chlorella, ashwagandha, rhodiola, Lactobacillus acidophilus (probiotic), CoQ10, milk thistle, alpha-lipoic acid, plus a standard multivitamin vitamin/mineral complex.

Third-party testing: NSF Certified for Sport — one of the most rigorous certifications in the supplement industry. This means every batch is tested for banned substances, heavy metals, and label accuracy.

The AG1 pitch: Replace 5–10 separate supplements with one scoop. Simplicity and convenience are the value proposition.

The Competitors

Thorne Daily Greens Plus

Price: $45–$55/month

Ingredients: 34 ingredients focused on greens, adaptogens, and digestive support

Testing: NSF Certified for Sport (same as AG1)

Taste: Mildly sweet, smooth texture. Better than most greens powders.

Thorne is one of the most trusted names in clinical-grade supplements. Their Daily Greens Plus is a more focused product than AG1 — fewer ingredients, but each one is dosed at clinically relevant levels. This is the key distinction: AG1 includes 75 ingredients, but many are present in a proprietary blend where individual doses are not disclosed. Thorne lists every ingredient with its exact dose.

The verdict: If ingredient transparency and clinical dosing matter to you, Thorne wins. It does not try to replace a multivitamin or probiotic — it focuses on greens and adaptogens and does them well. You would need to add a separate multivitamin and probiotic for full AG1-equivalent coverage, which brings the total cost closer to AG1's price.

Momentous Essential Greens

Price: $50–$60/month

Ingredients: 28 ingredients with a focus on gut health and antioxidants

Testing: NSF Certified for Sport

Taste: Clean, slightly earthy. Mixes well.

Momentous has built a strong reputation through partnerships with Huberman Lab and professional sports teams. Their Essential Greens is a clean, focused formula with transparent labeling (every ingredient and dose listed). The probiotic component is robust — 10 billion CFU of clinically studied strains — and the antioxidant profile is strong.

The verdict: Momentous is the closest direct competitor to AG1 in terms of quality and testing standards, at roughly 40% less cost. The ingredient list is shorter but more transparent. If you trust the Momentous brand (and there is good reason to), this is the best value alternative.

Bloom Greens

Price: $35–$40/month

Ingredients: 30+ ingredients focused on digestion and bloating

Testing: Third-party tested (not NSF Certified)

Taste: Mango, berry, and coconut flavors. Tastes more like a smoothie than a greens powder.

Bloom has become enormously popular on TikTok and Instagram, driven largely by its taste and branding. The product is positioned more for digestive comfort (bloating, gut health) than comprehensive nutrition. The ingredient quality is decent but the testing standards are a tier below AG1, Thorne, and Momentous.

The verdict: Bloom is the most accessible and best-tasting option. If your primary goal is digestive comfort and you are not looking for comprehensive vitamin/mineral coverage, it delivers at a lower price. But the lack of NSF certification and less rigorous testing makes it a tier below for health optimizers who care about what is actually in the product.

Transparent Labs Prebiotic Greens

Price: $35–$45/month

Ingredients: 23 ingredients with full label transparency

Testing: Third-party tested, transparent label

Taste: Mild, slightly sweet. Clean.

True to their name, Transparent Labs lists every ingredient with its exact dose — no proprietary blends. The formula focuses on prebiotic fiber, organic greens, and digestive enzymes. It is a clean, honest product at a reasonable price.

The verdict: The best option for people who want to know exactly what they are taking at exactly what dose. The ingredient list is shorter than AG1, but everything is clinically dosed and clearly labeled. At $35–$45/month, it is a strong value play.

The Comparison Table

| Feature | AG1 | Thorne | Momentous | Bloom | Transparent Labs |

|---------|-----|--------|-----------|-------|-----------------|

| Price/mo | $79–$99 | $45–$55 | $50–$60 | $35–$40 | $35–$45 |

| Ingredients | 75 | 34 | 28 | 30+ | 23 |

| NSF Certified | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | No |

| Transparent doses | Partial | Yes | Yes | Partial | Yes |

| Probiotics | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | No |

| Multivitamin | Yes | No | Partial | No | No |

| Taste | Good | Good | Good | Best | Good |

The Honest Assessment

AG1 is a good product. The NSF certification is legitimate. The ingredient breadth is unmatched. The taste is solid. The convenience of one scoop replacing multiple supplements is real.

AG1 is not a great value. You are paying a significant premium for convenience and brand. The proprietary blend means you cannot verify that individual ingredients are dosed at clinically relevant levels. And the marketing budget that puts AG1 in every podcast is funded by that $99/month price tag.

The math: If you replace AG1 with Momentous Essential Greens ($55) + a quality multivitamin ($15) + a standalone probiotic ($20), your total cost is $90/month with fully transparent dosing and NSF-level quality on the greens. You save $10/month and gain ingredient transparency.

If convenience is your top priority and you genuinely want one product to cover all bases, AG1 delivers. If value and transparency matter more, the competitors offer 80–90% of the benefit at 40–60% of the cost.

Key Takeaways

• AG1 is a solid product with legitimate NSF certification, but you are paying a premium for convenience and brand
• Momentous Essential Greens is the best value alternative with comparable quality at 40% less cost
• Thorne Daily Greens Plus is the best option for people who want clinical-grade, fully transparent dosing
• Bloom is the best-tasting and most accessible option, but a tier below on testing standards
• The real question is not "Is AG1 good?" (it is) but "Is the convenience worth $40–$60/month more than alternatives?"

Related articles:

• The Best Magnesium Supplements in 2026
• The Longevity Supplement Stack: What the Evidence Says
• Best Creatine Supplements in 2026

Affiliate Disclosure: This article may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we genuinely believe in. This helps support our work and allows us to continue providing free content.